On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe - Food.com (2024)

17

Submitted by Brandess

"When I was child, my oldest sister would take my nephew and I to a pizza place called 'Godfathers Pizza'- there are still a few around on the East Coast. I fell head over heels in love with their baked spaghetti! A dish they would make with the leftover spaghetti from the day before. For years I craved the specific flavor of the Godfather's sauce until one day I bought a jar of Classico Italian Sausage with Peppers and Onions spaghetti sauce. WOW! Was I shocked and happy to find it was almost exactly like I had remembered the Godfather's sauce to be. Recently I discovered that Newman's Own also makes a close second called Sockarooni Sauce! Either way, here is my recipe for Baked Spaghetti. I also encourage you to use either of these sauces on homemade pizza! Enjoy!"

Download

On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe - Food.com (2) On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe - Food.com (3)

photo by Little_Sister On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe - Food.com (4)

On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe - Food.com (5) On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe - Food.com (6)

Ready In:
40mins

Ingredients:
7
Serves:

6-8

Advertisem*nt

ingredients

  • 1 lb sweet Italian turkey sausage
  • 12 lb spaghetti
  • 18 teaspoon red pepper flakes
  • 1 (24 ounce) jar spaghetti sauce, Classico, Newman's Own, divided
  • 12 cup parmesan cheese, fresh grated not the ground kind
  • 12 cup sour cream
  • 1 cup Italian cheese blend, mozzarella

Advertisem*nt

directions

  • Pre-heat oven, or toaster oven, to 350 degrees.
  • Remove sausage from casings, crumble and brown in a frying pan until cooked through. Drain all oil from the sausage.
  • Mix the jar sauce with the sour cream. Ladle 1/4 cup of the sauce into the bottom of a 8x8, 9x9 or 10x10 baking dish. Top with 2 tsp of the fresh grated parmesan.
  • Meanwhile, cook spaghetti according to package directions, drain and toss with sausage, red pepper flakes, the remaining spaghetti sauce, 1/4 cup of the Parmesan cheese and 1/2 cup of the Italian cheese blend.
  • Place the spaghetti mixture on top of the sauce in the baking dish. Place the cheese mixture on top of the spaghetti.
  • Finish off with remaining cheese mixture on top.
  • Place baking dish in the oven for 20-25 minutes. Allow to cool for 10 minutes before serving with a crusty bread.
  • NOTE: The larger the dish you use, the thinner your recipe becomes in height. An 8x8 baking dish will yield a 3in high pie, whereas a 10x10 dish will yield a 2 inch high pie. You can also make this recipe with leftover spaghetti from a previous meal. Simply make sauce with the sour cream and mix with your spaghetti as in STEPS 3 & 4. Top off as in STEP 6 and bake as directed in STEP 7.

Questions & Replies

On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe - Food.com (7)

Got a question? Share it with the community!

Advertisem*nt

Reviews

  1. This was delicious! I only used 1/2 lb of turkey sausage and the "powdery" parmesan cheese because I am trying to stretch our food budget a little farther these days. It was still delicious and my 4 kids and 2 of their friends cleaned their plates and asked for seconds. I will definitely make this again. Thanks for the recipe!

    KeeperAtHome

  2. It had been a while since I made this, so I made it for dinner tonight with some homemade sauce my mom gave me. You can really make this with any spaghetti sauce. Adding the fresh, grated parmesan does make it better, but any Italian-type cheese blend will work.

    Meucci

  3. Nice change from the typical spaghetti and meat sauce! Had to modify some because of what I had on hand...instead of 16 ounces of turkey I had 19 ounces of regular sweet Italian sausage and instead of a 24 ounce jar I had a 32 ounce jar of spaghetti sauce so I increased everything else just a bit and baked in a 9 x 13 baking dish. Served with a mixed green salad and garlic knots for an easy and really tasty dinner.

    Little_Sister

  4. I used spicy Italian sausage, and this was very easy, tasty, and filling. I scaled the recipe in half, used a 1-1/2 qt oval casserole dish, and it would have adequately served 4 people. <br/>Clearly, with a nice homemade sauce it would have been 5 stars, but as an easy weeknight dish, it was really good.

    Chris 5

  5. Wow! We all loved this recipe, we will be making this more often.

    1baytown

see 11 more reviews

Advertisem*nt

Tweaks

  1. Quick, creamy, comforting, and satisfying! Since we've never been to the restaurant and needed to replicate a specific flavor, I used Francisco Rinaldi, which is the sauce I had on hand. I left out the red pepper flakes to keep it cool for the kiddos. My entire family loved this dish! I loved that it was made with sausage instead of beef, although I may someday try it with beef as well. Thanks for posting a delicious family friendly meal!

    ColCadsMom

  2. Excellent, fast and easy. I used ground turkey instead of sausage. My family loved it even the spaghetti expert, my daughter.

    Red_Apple_Guy

RECIPE SUBMITTED BY

Brandess

  • 49 Followers
  • 98 Recipes
  • 3 Tweaks

.

View Full Profile

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt

YOU'LL ALSO LOVE

Scallop Piccata on Spaghetti Squash

by GG 38966

1

Paella on Spaghetti Squash

by Boomette

How to Make Kombucha at Home

How to Grow a SCOBY (Kombucha Mothe...

View All Recipes

On the Fly Spaghetti Pie - Baked Spaghetti Recipe  - Food.com (2024)

FAQs

How can I make my spaghetti more interesting? ›

8 Ways to Elevate Canned Spaghetti Sauce
  1. 1 - Extra virgin olive oil. Adding a good amount of a flavorful olive oil will go a long way in infusing flavor into your sauce. ...
  2. 2 - Fresh garlic. ...
  3. 3 - Meat. ...
  4. 4 - Hot pepper flakes. ...
  5. 5 - Red wine. ...
  6. 6 - Fresh or dried herbs. ...
  7. 7 - Cheese. ...
  8. 8 - Cream and/or butter.
Feb 26, 2018

How to prepare white spaghetti? ›

The most popular way to cook spaghetti is simple. Put the pasta into plenty of boiling water, stir it, bring it to a simmer, turn the heat off, put a lid on and leave it to finish cooking for 10-12 mins.

How do you keep baked spaghetti from drying out? ›

A good rule of thumb is to make sure there is enough liquid to cover the pasta in the baking dish. Don't cover the baked spaghetti in the oven. It may seem necessary to cover the dish so that the cheese doesn't burn or the spaghetti doesn't dry out, but it's not important to do this.

Is baked spaghetti the same as lasagna? ›

The main differences are that you use thin spaghetti noodles instead of wide lasagna pasta, and you toss in a couple of beaten eggs with the cooked noodles. The eggs help bind the noodles in place so you can easily cut and serve even rectangles without them falling apart.

What is the secret to good spaghetti? ›

For the best spaghetti, cook it in salted water.

Pasta water should taste salty. I add a lot of salt to our pasta water (it makes the pasta taste delicious). I add about one tablespoon of salt for every four quarts (16 cups) of water, which is perfect for cooking one pound of pasta.

What makes spaghetti taste better? ›

13 Ways to Make Any Jarred Pasta Sauce Better
  1. Start with the right pasta and sauce. ...
  2. Season with dried herbs. ...
  3. Or flavor with fresh herb sprigs. ...
  4. Double up on tomato goodness. ...
  5. Add more garlic and/or onions. ...
  6. Sweeten and thicken with squash purée. ...
  7. Punch things up with a pinch of chili flakes. ...
  8. Try this secret ingredient.
Dec 9, 2022

What does adding milk to spaghetti do? ›

It sounds unconventional to use milk in a meaty red sauce, but upon further investigation, it makes total sense why Italians swear by it. According to our Food Director Amira, not only does milk add a rich flavour to the bolognese, but it also “helps cut through the acidity of the tomatoes and red wine”.

Why do you put baking soda in spaghetti? ›

If you don't have a package of ramen on-hand, “ramenize” your spaghetti by adding baking soda to a pot of water. It adds alkali, which is what gives ramen its chewy, bouncy texture and yellowish hue.

What is the white stuff on leftover spaghetti? ›

When you drain your pasta and water from the pot, leftover starch will build up on the walls of your pot, creating that plastic-like substance that has many people thinking they've melted their pot.

Why do you put salt in water before you make spaghetti? ›

When pasta is cooked in water, its starch granules take on water, swell, soften and release some of the starches, Harold McGee writes in “On Food and Cooking.” “Salt in the cooking water not only flavors the noodles, but limits starch gelation and so reduces cooking losses and stickiness,” he says.

What ingredient is spaghetti made of? ›

Like other pasta, spaghetti is made of milled wheat, water, and sometimes enriched with vitamins and minerals. Italian spaghetti is typically made from durum-wheat semolina.

What are the origins of baked spaghetti? ›

Oven-Baking Spaghetti : The History

In the early 19th century, Italian immigrants from Sicily arrived in New York City. They brought with them many types of traditional dishes; including, oven baked spaghetti . Many iterations of the recipe became popular.

What is pasta bake called in America? ›

Baked Ziti is an American classic pasta bake made with a tomato based meat sauce similar to Bolognese.

Why is baked pasta so good? ›

If there's anything more comforting than boiled pasta in a sauce, it's got to be baked pasta in a sauce. The baking adds a crispy crust that is such a delicious contrast to the tender goodness of the dish. The challenge is to how to get the pasta to turn out just right.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Corie Satterfield

Last Updated:

Views: 6453

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Corie Satterfield

Birthday: 1992-08-19

Address: 850 Benjamin Bridge, Dickinsonchester, CO 68572-0542

Phone: +26813599986666

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Table tennis, Soapmaking, Flower arranging, amateur radio, Rock climbing, scrapbook, Horseback riding

Introduction: My name is Corie Satterfield, I am a fancy, perfect, spotless, quaint, fantastic, funny, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.